Love and the Law: An exerpt from Bulleh Shah (Required reading if you have studied the law)
Bulleh Shah (1680 â€“ 1757) was a Punjabi Sufi poet, a humanist and philosopher from what is now considered Pakistan. As one of the leading figures in social thought and spiritualism, Bulleh Shah continually challenged the norms of society, be it materialism or hate for oneâ€™s fellow man.
While his work is expansive, the following passage was picked for a personal reason.Â Throughout my career as a law school student I have felt an internal stuggle between what I would call my â€œUniversal Selfâ€ (or innate sensibility of â€œfairnessâ€) and the technical nature of the law as embraced byÂ practioners and academics.Â Several justices over the years, theÂ worst of which isÂ Justice Scalia, have treated the cases that come before the US Supreme Court as a time to showcase thier talent of rationally explaing a inhuman or heartless decision by the court.
Most law school students in the first year, before they have been indoctrinated to accept the notion that injustice can/must be done in order to maintain the courtâ€™sÂ precedent, always raise questions of a court not deciding the â€œright wayâ€ even though the JusticesÂ were maintained a high level ofÂ technical legal analysis. That is because we come into law school believing in our own internal moral compass, again what I would call a relationship to the Universal Self, and the process of learning the law forces one to take actions that may violate oneâ€™s own moral code becuase it is the â€œtechnicallyâ€ correct thing to do.
So I present Bulleh Shahâ€™s verse which I will label as Love and Law. Though he presents teh argument as lambasting the laws created around religions by organizations and priests, but it easily translates to the abject focus on technical rationality in the modern legal forum.Â This has been a more significant and epiphany inducing peice than anything I have read in law school- so for all the young lawyers, PLEASE READ THIS!
Love and Law are struggling in the human heart.
The doubt of the heart will I settle by relating questions of Law
And the answers of Love I will describe, holy Sir;
Law says go to the Mullah (priest) and learn the rules and regulations.
Love answers,Â â€One letter is enough, shut up and put away other books.â€
Law says: Perform the five baths and worship alone in the temple (reffering to the 5x daily prayer of Muslims)
Love says: Your worship is false if you consider yourself seperate from the Universal Self.
Law says: Have shame and hideÂ the enlightenment
LoveÂ says: What is this veil for? Let the vision be open
Law says: Go inside the mosque and perform the duty of prayer
Love says: Go to the wine-house and drinking the wine, read a prayer
Law says: Let us go to heaven; we will eat the fruits of heaven
Love says: There, we are custodians or rulers, and we ourselves will distribute the fruits of heaven
Law says: O faithful one, come perform the hajj (pilgrimage), you have to cross the bridge
Love says: The door of the Beloved (God/Allah) is in kaâ€™baa; from there I will not stir
Law says:Â We placed Shah Mansur (a contraversial Sufi Saint) on the stake
Love says: You did well, you made him enter the door of the Beloved (God/Allah)
THE RANK OF LOVE IS THE HIGHEST HEAVEN, THE CROWN OF CREATION.
OUT OF LOVE, HE (Allah/ God) has created Bulleh, humble, and from dust.